The food has that upscale artisan pizza place vibe, and we really enjoyed everything we ordered. We tried the pear salad, wings, and pizza, and each dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully... The food has that upscale artisan pizza place vibe, and we really enjoyed everything we ordered. We tried the pear salad, wings, and pizza, and each dish was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. We decided to visit after seeing DineWithDom's recommendation, and it definitely lived up to the hype. We'll absolutely be back!
Real Pies. Real Flavor.
Tradition Baked Fresh Daily.
Johnny’s Pies is a cozy neighborhood pizzeria in Medford, New Jersey, known for its handcrafted pizzas made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and organic red wheat flour dough. The restaurant focuses on small-batch preparation, baking each 16-inch pie well-done for a perfectly crisp crust, and pairing it with homemade sauces, fresh salads, and oven-baked wings. Founded by friends with a passion for great food, Johnny’s Pies offers a welcoming spot where authentic flavors, carefully crafted recipes, and community spirit come together in every slice.
Fresh • Hot • Delicious
Join Us
Hours
Wed & Thu:04:00PM-08:00PM
Fri-Sat:12:00- 08:00PM
Sun:03:00PM-08:00PM
Call
Our Story
Three lifelong friends - Tom, Tim, and Pat—shared more than years of friendship; they shared a passion for great food. Turning that passion into reality, they opened a pizza shop founded on a simple idea: serve real food made the right way. Every pizza is prepared using organic, farm-fresh ingredients, carefully sourced and crafted with the same dedication that defines their friendship. Leading the kitchen is Tyler, Tom’s son and the talented chef behind the pies, adding skill, creativity, and a fresh generation of flavor to every slice. As their vision grew, the space expanded into a welcoming wine bar, offering thoughtfully selected bottles that pair perfectly with the menu. What began as a dream among friends has grown into a community gathering place where delicious pizza, fine wine, and great company come together.
Uncork The Flavor
Elevate your evening with the perfect pairing. We are thrilled to announce that our wine selection is now available! Whether you’re stopping by for a signature pizza or a hearty meatballs or baked wings, you can now complement your delicious dinner with a hand-selected bottle of Meadowcroft wine
About Us
At Johnnys Pies, we don’t just make pizza - we craft it with care. Our dough is unlike any other, made with the finest flour and unprocessed ingredients that demand delicate handling. Unlike traditional pizza shops that toss their dough into the air, we treat ours with the respect it deserves, gently working it to preserve its integrity and texture.We never freeze our dough—it's always fresh, always authentic. But such dedication takes time, and that’s why we can only make a limited number of pies each day. Quality isn’t rushed, and we wouldn’t have it any other way. Taste the difference.
Experience the craftsmanship
Featuring
Dine In
Take Out
Delivery
The Taste of Medford
Join Our Loyalty Program Today
Customers enrolled in our Loyalty Program are the first to hear about our special offers and promotions.
What people are talking about our services
Discover why our service is the buzz in town, where every detail is crafted to
elevate
your dining delight.
Berkie Gregs
Michael Brattelli
Since the new owners took over, this place has been absolutely amazing. The staff is incredibly friendly, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the pizza is outstanding. The pepperoni pizza is a... Since the new owners took over, this place has been absolutely amazing. The staff is incredibly friendly, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the pizza is outstanding. The pepperoni pizza is a must-try—easily one of the best around. Highly recommend!
Melissa Thompson
I had a little trouble getting through on the phone, but it was completely worth it! We ordered wings, salads, and pizza, and everything was absolutely delicious. The quality, freshness, and flavor... I had a little trouble getting through on the phone, but it was completely worth it! We ordered wings, salads, and pizza, and everything was absolutely delicious. The quality, freshness, and flavor were top-notch. This has definitely become one of our new favorite places.
Nicholas Santangelo
Everything here is incredibly fresh and full of flavor. Among all the pizza places in the Medford area, this one truly stands out. The artisan-style pizzas are exceptional, the ingredients are high... Everything here is incredibly fresh and full of flavor. Among all the pizza places in the Medford area, this one truly stands out. The artisan-style pizzas are exceptional, the ingredients are high quality, and the prices are surprisingly reasonable. A fantastic spot that I highly recommend!
Frequently Asked Questions
Johnny's Pies is located at 32 N Main St, Medford, NJ 08055.
We're open Wednesday-Thursday 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM, Friday-Saturday 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM, and Sunday 3:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
Johnny's Pies serves handcrafted 16-inch pizzas made with organic red wheat flour dough, homemade sauces, fresh salads, and oven-baked wings.
Yes! We offer dine-in and online ordering for pickup.
Yes! Sign up through our online ordering page to get early access to special offers and promotions.